As we all know, when Republicans hold the levers of power on Capitol Hill, you can expect to see a lot of sheer lunacy masquerading as policy and debate. A classic case of this came when the Republicans on the House Science Committee saw fit to effectively give its sanction to climate change denial.
Late Thursday afternoon, committee chairman Lamar Smith and his fellow Republicans saw fit to blast this out on the committee’s Twitter feed.
.@BreitbartNews: Global Temperatures Plunge. Icy Silence from Climate Alarmists https://t.co/uLUPW4o93V
— Sci,Space,&Tech Cmte (@HouseScience) December 1, 2016
The link goes to an article from Breitbart–or rather, Trumpbart–that claims a one-degree drop in land temperatures proves the lie to overwhelming evidence that this is the planet’s hottest year on record. What Trumpbart doesn’t tell you is that the oceans have absorbed much of that warmth. Apparently those facts aren’t enough for committee chairman Lamar Smith, who is notorious for drinking the climate change denial Kool-Aid by the barrelful.
It turns out that you can add another item to the long list of sins from Trumpbart. Under Steve Bannon’s watch, Trumpbart has been one of the loudest promoters of climate change denial. Its main climate change skeptic, James Delingpole, wrote the piece that was so loudly trumpeted by Smith. Delingpole openly admits he isn’t a scientist, but thinks he can legitimately chide them. Back in 2013, he harrumphed that climate scientists were “talentless low-lives” and “abject liars.” Before then, he had suggested that the arguments for climate change are so ridiculous that death is too good for climate scientists.
When Bernie Sanders saw this roll across his phone, he let Smith and friends have it.
Where'd you get your PhD? Trump University? https://t.co/P5Ez5fVEwD
— Bernie Sanders (@SenSanders) December 1, 2016
You’ll have to pardon Sanders and his social media team for sounding so incredulous. After all, Sanders was on hand when Jim Inhofe peddled similar nonsense in 2015–and got torn apart by Sheldon Whitehouse. As Whitehouse pointed out, the only people who give climate change denial any credence at all are “conspiracy theorists,” people who aren’t willing to accept “scientific truths,” and people with financial ties to oil and gas interests. Unfortunately, we got the message loud and clear today that those elements are now charged with oversight of our environmental policy.
Ranking Democrat Eddie Bernice Johnson and the other Dems on the Science Committee gave their Republican counterparts a cold dose of facts.
The Committee Democrats look to our respected scientists @NOAA and @NASA for our climate data.
— Science Committee (@SciCmteDems) December 1, 2016
2015 beat the record set in 2014 by 0.29°F-largest margin a year has beaten another since records began in 1880 → https://t.co/GmGCJvbQX4
— Science Committee (@SciCmteDems) December 1, 2016
9 of the 10 warmest years on record have occurred since 2000. Not including this year. → https://t.co/bW3qBWr0iW
— Science Committee (@SciCmteDems) December 1, 2016
One of the committee’s Democrats, Don Beyer of Virginia, was so dumbfounded that he felt the need to weigh in with a tweet of his own.
This isn't factual, it's embarrassing, and Breitbart is not a credible news source. We need to bring *science* back to the Science Committee https://t.co/oZ6GfFAlUI
— Rep. Don Beyer (@RepDonBeyer) December 1, 2016
Beyer also trolled the GOP when he announced he had just sent out his latest newsletter on climate change.
My weekly #ClimateChange newsletter is called #JustTheFacts. Sign up here if you'd like it https://t.co/ds9CeMhIrd
We don't cite fake news. https://t.co/tj4NAoAoBK
— Rep. Don Beyer (@RepDonBeyer) December 1, 2016
Several actual scientists also joined in on the smackdown. First up, Peter Gleick of the National Academy of Sciences.
This is fake news, bad science, and basically, crap, from the House Science committee. #climate@HouseScience @BreitbartNews @LamarSmithTX21 https://t.co/60QTHEzO49
— Peter Gleick (@PeterGleick) December 1, 2016
Dear @HouseScience, tweeting fake, false science news from @BreitbartNews makes you look really, really bad. Attn: @LamarSmithTX21
— Peter Gleick (@PeterGleick) December 1, 2016
Katharine Hayhoe of the Texas Tech Climate Science Center launched a tweetstorm against this ridiculous article.
A classic example of false news. https://t.co/ECOkzeBW9j
The truth? pic.twitter.com/zEZGzOF7vi
— Katharine Hayhoe (@KHayhoe) December 1, 2016
Fake news is big these days. How can you tell if the latest climate headline is fake? Here's a handy guide.
— Katharine Hayhoe (@KHayhoe) December 1, 2016
You know it's fake news if (1) it calls scientists "alarmists" + science "alarmism," like this: Rebutting Climate Alarmism with Simple Facts
— Katharine Hayhoe (@KHayhoe) December 1, 2016
You know it's fake news if (2) it uses the words lie, hoax, phony, conspiracy, like this: Climate Change: The Hoax That Costs Us $4B a Day
— Katharine Hayhoe (@KHayhoe) December 1, 2016
You know it's fake news if (3) it cites authorities who aren't actually climate scientists: Former NASA Scientists..Dispute Climate Change
— Katharine Hayhoe (@KHayhoe) December 1, 2016
And finally, it might just be fake news if it makes you go, whaaaat?! like: Updated NASA Data: Global Warming Not Causing Polar Ice Retreat
— Katharine Hayhoe (@KHayhoe) December 1, 2016
There’s a reason that Gleick and Hayhoe were so dumbfounded. As we all know, sea levels are rising as the icecaps melt, putting major cities in danger. Seen in this light, this tweet from the Science Committee Republicans isn’t just wrong. It’s extremely dangerous.
Given the circumstances, it’s only fair to ask–are the Republicans on this committee okay with promoting this kind of hokum? Perhaps we should force them on the record. Here’s a list of the Republicans on the panel who are returning to Congress next year.
- Lamar Smith, chairman (TX-21)
- Frank Lucas, vice chairman (OK-03)
- Jim Sensenbrenner, Wisconsin (WI-05)
- Dana Rohrabacher, CA-48
- Mike McCaul, TX-10
- Mo Brooks, AL-05
- Randy Hultgren, IL-14
- Bill Posey, FL-08
- Thomas Massie, KY-04
- Jim Bridenstine, OK-01
- Randy Weber, TX-14
- Bill Johnson, OH-06
- John Moolenaar, MI-04
- Steve Knight, CA-25
- Brian Babin, TX-36
- Bruce Westerman, AR-04
- Barbara Comstock, VA-10
- Dan Newhouse, WA-04
- Gary Palmer, AL-06
- Barry Loudermilk, GA-11
- Ralph Abraham, LA-05
If either of these Republicans represent you, pester them on Facebook, on Twitter, and on email–politely, of course. If they are okay with giving climate change denial a stamp of approval, the American people deserve to know.